Everyone went home a winemaker
Have you ever blended your own wine?
A wine-blending experience at a Tuscan villa
Reading time : 5 min
Yes, a private wine tasting can become the heart of an evening at your Tuscan villa. I bring the wines, the glasses and the stories, and your group stays together around one table. Let me tell you what happened when twelve Dutch friends asked me to turn their villa evening into a winemaking game.
They’d been planning this Tuscany trip for months: a proper reunion, as they’d all known each other since college. They arrived with historical cars with that energy that old friends have when they finally get the band back together.
Loud, a little chaotic, ready for anything.
I ran them through my favorite tasting of the season: Winemaker for a Day. And I have to say: this group took it very seriously. Or at least they pretended to, which is honestly just as fun.
It starts with a little education. Three glasses, three very different grapes: Sangiovese, Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot. We taste them slowly, one by one, and try to put into words what makes each one what it is.
The earthy pull of the Sangiovese. The way the Cabernet wants to take up space. What the Merlot gives you that the others don’t. By the end of this part, everyone thinks they know exactly what they’re doing.
That confidence is half the fun.
Then comes the real challenge. Each person gets a graduated cylinder and goes off on their own — no sharing strategies, no peeking — to build their personal Bolgheri-style Super Tuscan blend. You can try up to two versions before you commit. Some people are decisive. Others agonize. A few talked a big game during the tasting and then completely second-guessed themselves once they were holding the cylinder.
There was a lot of fun talk going around that table!!
Once everyone locked in their final blend, the glasses came in anonymous and I tasted them blind, talking through each one out loud, what I was picking up, what choices seemed to be behind it, how close it got to the style the person was after.
It’s one of my favorite moments in this whole format.
You can tell a lot about someone from the wine they build.
The blind jury voted, a winner was crowned, and he walked away with a bottle of Metodo Classico. Bubbles are always perfect to celebrate! His friends will probably never let him forget it!
Thank you for being part of these stories. Every Thursday I get to share a little piece of what I do, and the fact that you’re here reading means a lot to me.
I hope one day you’ll get to live one of these experiences firsthand: with your people, in a villa, with a cylinder in your hand and no idea what you’re doing. That’s usually when the best memories happen.
If you ever want to make it real, just write to me.
I’d love to be part of your story too!
That evening is one example of how wine can bring a group together at a Tuscan villa. If you are staying in Tuscany and would like to plan a private wine tasting for your own group, explore my villa tastings and tell me where you will be staying. We can discuss an evening that suits you.
From Tuscany, with gratitude and a raised glass,
Claudia 🍷
By Claudia Callegari, DipWSET Level 4 Certified sommelier. I lead private wine tastings at Tuscan villas, visits to small wineries and the Toscana Wine Club.
Reviewed and updated on October 20, 2026.
A Brunello tasting in the middle of the night
A few months ago, while talking with Luciano from SanLorenzo in Montalcino about the release of the new Brunello di Montalcino 2021, I had a thought…
Three years later, in London
I found myself in London, holding something that is much more than a Diploma. That moment, simple as it may seem from the outside, carried the weight of a decision I made…
Montalcino Ancient History
Let’s delve into the ancient history that makes this place so special in Tuscany, dating back the medieval times!
Ready to explore the world of wine?
Join our Wine Club and get access to the best hand-picked selection of wines and experiences.
